Wolf Theiss lawyers Stefan Riegler, Dalibor Valincic and Oleg Temnikov analyse the involvement of state parties in arbitration, which may imply specific procedural issues. Concluding the discussion of the topics below is a short commentary on practical implications.
- Which rules apply?
- IBA Rules, Article 9
- Grounds of commercial or technical confidentiality in practice
- Special political or institutional sensitivity in practice
- Illegally obtained evidence and leaks of information
- Practical implications in taking evidence from state parties
Introduction
The involvement in arbitration of states, public authorities (such as government agencies, municipalities or other local authorities), or publicly owned enterprises may imply specific procedural issues. Indeed, the involvement of such public entities in arbitration led to the development of certain procedural mechanisms to secure their participation in a fair and balanced way. From bifurcation of proceedings to direct enforcement under the Convention on the Settlement of Investment Disputes between States and Nationals of Other States (the ICSID Convention), the approach has often been to create specific rules to address the standing of public entities. The interrelationship between the objectives of arbitration and the specifics of public entities, such as their immunities, the public interest objectives and considerations, have resulted in particularities widely discussed by scholars.
As concerns evidence, however, for a long time there were no particularly elaborated or detailed specific rules. The reason for this, at least in part, is the flexibility inherent in arbitration, which allows arbitral tribunals to use their discretion to account for the participation of public entities by adapting practices to the needs of a given arbitration procedure. Nevertheless, with an increase in arbitrations involving public entities, whether under investment protection instruments or under commercial contracts, some specific rules have emerged, which are also relevant to evidentiary issues.
When approaching the question of ‘special issues arising when taking evidence from state parties’, there are a couple of points about the possible nature of state parties that need to be taken into consideration. The most clear-cut example is when a state itself is taking part in proceedings, which is typically the case in investment treaty arbitrations. However, in international arbitration there are numerous examples of the respondent being a specific public authority (such as a government agency), a local authority (such as a municipality, federal unit of state or other local authority) or a fully or partially publicly owned enterprise. Although the rules of evidence may differ somewhat, such as in the case of sovereign immunity, which is often available only for the state itself, the general considerations relating to evidence bear some similarities and may be applied analogously.
The special issues around the taking of evidence in arbitration involving state parties are usually regarded from the perspective of obtaining evidence from a state party at the request of a private party. Indeed, arbitrations involving state parties are regularly asymmetric in their nature, as they involve private parties on the one side and state parties on the other. Therefore, even when the issues of taking evidence are considered in the context of a private party’s possibilities to obtain evidence from the state party, the asymmetry of the relationship may also create salient issues the other way round, that is when state parties produce evidence to which a private party would normally not have access.
For more information, contact the authors below or get in touch with a Wolf Theiss office in your local area.
Original published in: Global Arbitration Review – The Guide to Evidence in International Arbitration
Read the full text
Special issues arising when taking evidence from state parties
Wolf Theiss lawyers Stefan Riegler, Dalibor Valincic and Oleg Temnikov analyse the involvement of state parties in arbitration, which may imply specific procedural issues. Concluding the discussion of the topics below is a short commentary on practical implications. Which rules apply? IBA Rules, Article 9 Grounds of commercial or technical confidentiality in practice Special political […]...
Legal insights on corporate governance – Czech Republic, Poland and Romania
Czech Republic What are the current topical issues, developments, trends and challenges in corporate governance? There are a number of issues relating to the amendment to the Business Corporations Act, which are as follows: One-tier Board structure The powers of the Board of Directors were redefined with respect to the difficulties with division of powers […]...
Wolf Theiss advises Bain Capital on its investment in Berlin Brands Group
Bratislava, 10 September 2021 – Wolf Theiss has advised Bain Capital, an American private investment firm, on its investment in the international e-commerce company Berlin Brands Group operating in the direct-to-consumer sector. As one of the legal advisors to Bain Capital, Wolf Theiss advised the private equity firm on buying a minority stake in Berlin […]...
Wolf Theiss advises PSG on the acqusition of TIPCO Treasury & Technology GmbH
Vienna, 8 September 2021 – Wolf Theiss advises PSG on the legal and regulatory aspects of the acquisition of TIPCO Treasury & Technology GmbH, the leading specialist for treasury reporting software in the DACH region. A multidisciplinary team led by M&A Partner Sarah Wared advises PSG on all legal aspects of the transaction, including the […]...
The shareholder rights and activism review – Austria chapter
2020 saw a downward trend in the proportion of M&A-related activist campaigns due to a slower M&A activity, whereby M&A remained the most common campaign objective. However, recent activism-related trends indicate that the global and Austrian landscape is shifting, and companies' strategies for dealing with activism should therefore also evolve. ESG activism gained momentum and the pressure for public companies to adhere to best ESG practices will continue to intensify. Sarah Wared's contribution deals as a primer on the aspects of shareholder activism in Austria....
E-signatures: how they are regulated and how to use them
European legislation introduced the concept of electronic signatures in 1999 when the Directive on a Community framework for electronic signatures was adopted (the so called eSignature Directive). A further step was taken in July 2016 when the eIDAS Regulation came into force and set the ground for a level playing field across all EU member […]...
Austria chapter in the lending and secured finance review
Leopold Höher authored the Austria Chapter in the 7th edition of The Lending and Secured Finance Review....
Re-purposing real estate: adding value to your property
Deep changes in the global real estate market Panta rhei – „Everything flows“. When the Greek philosopher Heraclitus created this famous phrase around 500 B.C., it was certainly not the world of real estate that he had in mind. Nowadays, however, his quote aptly describes the developments that affect this critical investment class, which is […]...
Life sciences in CEE after COVID-19: growth, decline or stagnation?
Despite the pandemic, the CEE M&A market in Life Sciences / Healthcare remains stable with substantial growth expected The M&A market in this sector remained active in 2020 in Central and Eastern Europe, and investors have actually been showing increasing interest because the pandemic has not impacted its performance. Quite to the contrary, the pandemic […]...
Medien und Recht: Urheberrechtliche Aspekte von Non-Fungible Token
Artikel "Urheberrechtliche Aspekte von Non-Fungible Token" verfasst von Georg Kresbach und Elisabeth Zhang in Medien und Recht 4/21....
Wolf Theiss closed a fifth transaction in the tech sector in 2021, the sale of AMC RO Studio to Keywords Studios plc
Bucharest, 12 August 2021 – Wolf Theiss has advised the founders of AMC RO Studio, a world-leading 3D art and design studio that makes creative 3D visual development and design, creating concept art and motion graphics for games, film and digital media, in the sale of their shares to Keywords Studios plc, a publicly listed […]...
Financial Services Industry: Past, Present & Future
In July 2021, the European Central Bank confirmed that it is going to be proceeding with its digital Euro project. How will this decision impact the Financial Services Industry? Our guest speakers, Silvia Attanasio – Head of Innovation at ABI – and Petko Karamotchev – CEO of Industria Technology – have been involved in the implementation […]...